Animal Collective
Animal Collective Community Forum
Billy Joel
Tweet
  • I've been listening to Piano Man, the album, over and over again. I wrote this review that you totally don't have to read, but please continue discussion of this incredible singer/songwriter:

    "Well you're 21 and you're mom still makes your bed"

    Every time I think music is losing its novelty, something like this pulls me back in. The pure vulnerability of this album combined with such high quality 70s production is truly a blessed aesthetic experience. Every track tells a story, brings you into Joel's center of gravity and not a second of space is not contemplated nor is a single melody not living up to its full potential. Joel has this way of communicating such solemn themes in a light-hearted, free and fun manner that enraptures the listener. You are sitting there, hanging on his every word. His voice is an encouraging friend peer pressuring you into gliding along with every choral high, and yet, his grounded personality holds your hand on the come down -- the verses. You want to listen and you want to hear more.

    I used to think that Classic Rock -- it's as if I was out of mind thinking that I could really relate to it. What's so great about my life that warrants such a massive backdrop? Then I realized, that there's no way that this music is meant solely for those who have a lifestyle that affords such grandiose orchestration. This is meant for those solitary walks of purposeless, for those times when you are in a relationship that isn't anything particularly mind-blowing -- but it's your own and that's where your life is.

    Do not feel like these songs cannot personify every action you take just because they are so well-crafted. In comparison, your life may feel inadequate -- break down that node of thought. Joel is trying to elevate you from this place and take you into a world where you and the music are not just on an equal level. It's a world where you both see eye-to-eye and your ability to listen is just as important as the stories and the songs being sung. Through risking coming across as awkward, Billy Joel's "Piano Man" levels with the audience. The cover art is the proof. That man, those tired, longing eyes are where these songs came from. We are all that man, getting tired from the once profound novelties of day-to-day life and these songs are our soundtrack, our backdrop, aging with our lives and allowing us to understand both the music and ourselves with greater and greater complexity.

    I am thankful to live in the era I do when there is no reason not to listen to any style of music, because my biases may have prevented me from this very moving listen had I grown up in another era. Perhaps in another time, I may have allowed the trends of the present to overshadow the substance of past culture. Thankfully, that has not happened.
  • JFK BLOWN AWAY

    WHAT ELSE DO I HAVE TO SAY?!!!
  • I kinda get tired of that song and some of the worst music I can think of is over-played Billy Joel. But think to what it was like when you first heard that song, when you first heard Piano Man -- incredible!
  • I think Billy Joel is a talented singer-songwriter who has written many good songs and much like Fountains of Wayne, one of my favorite bands, he has a way of story telling about ordinary people doing ordinary things.

    By the way, I like the way you resist biasing bands and artists.
  • damn i used to love fountains of wayne!

    the first 2 albums were great and 3rd one was so under-grated because of the crossover overplayed hit so everyone wrote them off as some annoying one hite blunder! gah!

    their last album before the latest one and the latest one aren't quite as good but still pretty rather good!

    and of course i always think of THAT THING YOU DO!
  • He definitely has a knack for writing about the ordinary but making it sound EXTRAordinary...forgive the throwupinyourmouth cliche lmao, but point stands...

    I really try to be unbiased but I have a long way to go, still so much more music I need to open myself up to.
  • before you can open up yr mind you must open yr heart

    but before you can do that you must...

    open up yr throat!

    AND LET THE SUNSHINE IN!
  • I REALLY WANT TO DO JUST WHAT MY BODY WANTS TO
  • Glad to see someone else likes FOW, the first three albums were great, but the last two were just good and maybe a little bit bland.
  • i'm going to check them out
  • Good for you Calvin, I recommend their first two albums first, then you can decide if their third is worth a listen.
  • billy joel gets a lot of shit for being mediocre/middle of the road and in truth, some of that criticism sticks, but he's got so much good stuff. it's like saying dylan's a bad singer or has shitty albums: yeah, it's true, but so what? look at the rest of the corpus and it's holy shit one guy did this? (see also: phil collins)
  • I think if you look at someone long enough, you'll see mediocrity. I think we just choose the sides we want to see from people in culture. Some people just have better image control and are better at preserving the memory, but I almost respect it more when people just put out everything without regard for whether or not it will disgrace their carefully constructed brand. Like imagine if Bob Dylan just stopped after 1970?
  • well, dylan's shit 70s work was intentional to get rid of his 'dylan is a prophet! dylan is a spokesman for our blahblahblah' image. i'd say even early joel has some meh moments.
  • but 'all the tired horses' is one of the greatest songs ever





  • Calvin, I am so happy you have joined us. I should put that in the Things That Make me happy thread.

    Billy Joel memories:

    TV show Bososm Buddies, starring Tom Hanks as a cross-dressing male in an all girls rooming house. Theme song was 'My Life'. Loved it. In the part "I never said you had to offer me a second chance", Tom is doing this arm exercise stretchy thing. Crystal clear memory.

    Big Shot- "spoon up your nose". "Mom, what does that mean?" oh you had to be a beeeg shot deeed ya...

    When 'Pressure' came out it blew our socks off. We were 12, on the cusp of the strange morph into puberty with all the hormones and confusion. And an adult was saying HE felt crazy? The video shows him in a psych ward and we were like, "wow...adults feel this way, too?!"
    MTV had only been around for a year and so all the videos had MEANING (whether they meant to or not).
    His albums are in my rotation (along with lately, The Cars)

  • That must have been a wild time to be alive, ad the advent of MTV. Damn. Meaningfulcore at it's peak.

    Listening to Captain Jack, by myself right now on a Saturday night :(
  • Meaningfulcore!!! I will have to share that with my fellow children of the 70's.
  • Meaningfulcore is my favorite genre of music.
Tweet

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!